From Steel Town to Steal Town: Real Estate Bargains in the Rust Belt

Written by Pat O'Donnell

Published on August 11, 2016

There is a new awakening on Warrington Avenue. This South Pittsburgh thoroughfare of the formerly beleaguered neighborhood of Allentown is newly thriving. Storefront shutters lift, restaurant kitchens sizzle, and neighbors bustle by on their way to work and school.1
Alongside these outward aspects of the neighborhood's return to stability, the resurgence of the greater Pittsburgh economy has also brought eager real estate investors. A look at Data USA's statistics on property values shows why.
Home values in Pittsburgh lag national average home values—with a significantly higher relative percentage of homes in the $30,000-$125,000 price range.
View Data
Save Image
Add Data to Cart
In fact, median home values in the Pittsburgh metro area were only $134,700 in 2014, a full $50k less than the national median value.
Allentown's opportunities for Pittsburgh real estate investors are emblematic of the kind of deals available to those wishing to capitalize on the rebirth of America's great Rust Belt cities.2 While the Rust Belt's economy has rebounded somewhat since the great recession,3 its real estate values are still remarkably affordable.
Prices in Buffalo, NY are even lower -- well more than half of the city's homes are sold for less than $100,000. Median property values in the Buffalo metro area in 2014 were $123,400, according to the American Community Survey. Investors that are able to take advantage of these low prices are betting that values will eventually rise to match the acceleration of local economies.
Of course, just saying that something has a low price doesn't mean that it's a good deal. Rust Belt cities also offer a number of cultural and infrastructure advantages which complement their low prices and make them attractive places for many people to live. Short commute times, low tax rates, and cultural amenities provide accommodating environments for young professionals that defy urban stereotypes of expensive and inaccessible cities. A look at the quality of life indicators in Data USA shows us some of these factors.
Many Rust Belt cities have relatively low traffic congestion. At 20.5 minutes, Buffalo's average one-way commute time is 20% lower than the national average, illustrated in the graphic below.
View Data
Save Image
Add Data to Cart
When compared to its intra-state neighbor of New York City, the difference is even more dramatic, as Buffalo residents take 50 percent less time to get to work than their Big Apple counterparts. Milwaukee's average commute time is similarly low at only 22.2 minutes.
Many rust belt cities offer more cultural amenities than other cities around the country. Their history of gilded-age philanthropy has often endowed them with museums and art schools which make them cultural nuclei. St. Louis has a concentration of museums, art galleries, and historical sites greater than Santa Fe, New Mexico's – an internationally-known art colony. St. Louis City PUMA's comparative advantage for the 'Museums, art galleries, historical sites, and similar institutions' industry group is 6.18, compared with Santa Fe's 4.71.4 Both Detroit (#25) and St. Louis (#27) rank in the top 30 of the Pantheon index for cultural production since 1900, topping more well-known cultural hubs such as Milan (#32) and Barcelona (#35).5
By 'buying low' from the Rust-belt's stock of former homes of steel workers and machinists, the next generation of skilled professionals in these cities may take comfort in the soundness of their housing investment. Residents of Allentown and other urban neighborhoods face a unique opportunity to invest in their places of residence with the likelihood of a favorable return.6
Meanwhile in Allentown, storefronts continue to fill in Warrington Avenue's once barren retail corridor and the rhythm of a thriving community resounds with community real estate investors, eager to capitalize on the Rust Belt's rebirth.
  1. Boselovic, Len. "Rising Allentown Shines on Small Business Saturday." Pittsburgh Post-Gazette 29 November 2015. Web. 21 April 2016.
  2. Milligan, Susan. "An Urban Revival in the Rust Belt." US News and World Reports 2 September 2014. Web. 21 April 2016.
  3. Kotkin, Joel and Shires, Michael. "The Cities Leading a U.S. Manufacturing Revival." Forbes 23 July 2015. Web. 21 April 2016.
  4. See
  5. Yu, A. Z., et al. (2016). Pantheon 1.0, a manually verified dataset of globally famous biographies. Scientific Data 2:150075. doi: 10.1038/sdata.2015.75.
  6. O'Neill, Brian. "Rising home prices tell Pittsburgh's uplifting story." Pittsburgh Post-Gazette 8 January 2014. Web. 21 April 2016.
Pat O'Donnell

Pat is a Business Technology Analyst with Deloitte Consulting's Technology practice, specializing in large-scale custom application implementations for Public Sector clients. He is passionate about his work in the Child Welfare space, where he leads technical teams to assist clients in addressing the needs of their most vulnerable populations. Pat is also passionate about his home of Pittsburgh, PA, where he is personally renovating a century-old family home and actively participating in the city's revitalization.